La Grande senior Gabe Shukle was named as the 2019 GOL defensive player of the year. Here is the complete defensive list.
| Defensive POV |
| La Grande – Gabe Shukle -12 |
1st Team
| Defensive Linemen |
| La Grande -Gabe Shukle 12 |
| Baker – Sam McCauley 12 |
| Baker – Ethan Myers 11 |
| La Grande – Chris Woodworth 12 |
| Defensive Backs |
| La Grande – Dawson Gaertner 12 |
| La Grande – Blaine Shaw 12 |
| Baker – Andrew Adams 12 |
| Baker – Kaden Meyer 11 |
| Linebackers |
| La Grande – Nathan Reed 12 |
| La Grande – Zach Wiggins 12 |
| Baker – Jake Eskew 11 |
| Baker – Gauge Bloomer 10 |
| Punter |
| Baker – Caden Long 12 |
2nd Team
| Defensive Linemen |
| La Grande – Spencer Gerst 12 |
| La Grande – Eli Leavitt 12 |
| Ontario – Zar Ramirez 12 |
| Baker – Jake Wright 11 |
| Defensive Backs |
| La Grande – Josh Zollman 12 |
| Ontario – Ruben Hernandez 10 |
| Baker – Alex Hammans 12 |
| Baker – Riley Flanagan 12 |
| Linebackers |
| La Grande – Casey Cornford 11 |
| La Grande – Parker Robinson 12 |
| Baker – Hon Rushton 11 |
| Ontario – Brandon Rodriguez 12 |
| Punter |
| La Grande – Casey Cornford 11 |
Honorable Mention
| Defensive Linemen |
| La Grande – Kieth Oswald 12 |
| Ontario – Ruben Chavez 11 |
| Baker – Mason VanArdall 11 |
| Baker – Zander Arriaga 11 |
| Defensive Backs |
| La Grande – Justin Jenner 12 |
| Baker – Gabe Gambleton 11 |
| Linebacker |
| La Grande – Broay McMillan 10 |
